Peterson, Johnson & Murray – Chicago LLC
Chicago Attorneys
Menu
  • Home
  • About Us
    • Firm Profile
    • Our Clients
    • Close
  • Attorneys
    • Attorneys
    • Paul A. O’Grady
    • Dominick L. Lanzito
    • Kevin M. Casey
    • Ajay Shah
    • Deanna Rosenbaum Hall
    • Jennifer Turiello
    • Joselyn R. Mathews
    • Patrick G. Connelly
    • Shantel I. Perez
    • Thomas J. Condon, Jr.
    • Kevin Kearney
    • Thomas Nelligan
    • Close
  • Areas of Practice
    • Areas of Practice
    • Municipal Law
    • Municipal Litigation
    • Civil Rights / ADA / Employment Law
    • Personal Injury & Property Damage
    • Labor & Employment
    • Gaming Law
    • Reinsurance & Regulatory Practice
    • Appellate Representation
    • Insurance Coverage Issues
    • Worker’s Compensation Litigation
    • Corporate & Commercial Law
    • Professional Liability
    • Close
  • Legal Blog
  • Contact Us
March 26, 2019

Long Term Solutions for Short Term Rentals

Municipal Law, Rental Regulations

By Patrick Connelly & Joselyn Varghese

Short term vacation rentals are one of the fastest growing businesses in the country today. They are a part of rising trend of startup companies facilitating individuals to share what one person already owns. It started with ride-sharing that continues to achieve massive success. However, the attention is now shifting to short term vacation rentals as cities and municipalities attempt to regulate.

The purpose behind companies like Airbnb is to fill the gaps for rooms or even homes people do not occupy year-round. This gives homeowners the opportunity to bring in additional income and allows travelers to find low cost accommodations. While this concept has been more or less accepted in major American cities, its expansion has created some anxiety. As municipalities continue to create regulations for short term vacation rentals within their boundaries, Airbnb is fighting back both in the courts and through increased lobbying efforts. Their success has varied. 
 
The 9th Circuit Court of Appeals recently issued a major blow to short term vacation rentals when it sided with the City of Santa Monica in their long standing dispute with Airbnb and HomeAway,[1] which it claims violated the Communications Decency Act. The Santa Monica ordinance allows “home sharing” where residents can rent space in their homes to visitors so long as the homeowner is present. Further, the Santa Monica ordinance places liability directly on the companies like Airbnb for removing any ads that do not comply with Santa Monica’s ordinances. Airbnb argued in part that Santa Monica’s ordinance violated the Communications Decency Act as it holds the company liable for the actions of their users. The 9th Circuit did not agree finding that the ordinance was a proper use of local authority and that “like their brick and mortar counterparts, internet companies must also comply with any number of local regulations concerning for example, employment, tax, or zoning.”
 
In Illinois, a new bill, HB 2919[2], attempts to limit municipalities’ authority to regulate short term rentals. If passed, any short-term vacation rental ordinance must be for the purpose of protecting, “public health, safety, sanitation, traffic control, solid or hazardous waste control, pollution control, and other specified circumstances.” Notably missing in this definition is a mention of preserving a municipalities’ housing stock and preserving the quality and nature of residential neighborhoods. Illinois municipalities should be monitoring the effect of short term vacation rentals for public health, safety, sanitation, and traffic control within their boundaries, and be ready to provide factual justifications to support any short term vacation rental regulation.

Leaders in the field, such as Airbnb, have shown a willingness to challenge local regulations in court and are lobbying to restrict local authorities through state legislation. Municipalities must be prepared to justify their regulations upon proper grounds or risk later attack. 

If you have any questions feel free to contact us below.  Thank you.

Patrick Connelly
Phone: 312-724-8033
Email: pconnelly@pjmchicago.com

Joselyn Varghese
Phone: 312-724-8039
Email: jvarghese@pjmchicago.com

Illinois Supreme Court Clarifies Law Governing Admissibility of Post-Accident Vehicular Photographs Department of Labor to Set Prevailing Wages by July 15th

Related Posts

Illinois Applelate Court, Municipal Law

Illinois Municipal Law: Stormwater Fee Upheld by Illinois Appellate Court

Municipal Law

Illinois Municipal Law & the “Leveling the Playing Field for Illinois Retail Act”: We’re in the Money

Illinois Marijuana Law, Municipal Law

Legalization of Marijuana & It’s Impact on Law Enforcement

Search

Categories

  • Firearm Dealer License Certification Act
  • First Admendment
  • FOIA
  • Government Severance Act
  • Gun Trafficking Information Act
  • Illinois Applelate Court
  • Illinois Firearm Concealed Carry Act
  • Illinois Gaming Expansion Law
  • Illinois Marijuana Law
  • Illinois Peer-to-Peer Car Sharing Act
  • Illinois Raffles and Poker Runs Act
  • Illinois Supreme Court
  • Local Government and Governmental Employees Tort Immunity Act
  • Municipal Law
  • Open Meeting Act (OMA)
  • Prevailing Wage Act
  • Rental Regulations
  • Statue of Limitations
  • Uncategorized

Recent Posts

  • FOIA: Ongoing Murder Investigation Not Enough to Claim Blanket Exemption According to First District Illinois Appellate Court Ruling
  • Illinois Municipal Law: Stormwater Fee Upheld by Illinois Appellate Court
  • Illinois Municipal Law & the “Leveling the Playing Field for Illinois Retail Act”: We’re in the Money
  • Gaming Expansion Law: Illinois Bets Big
  • Illinois Cannabis Legislation Impact on the Workplace

Archives

  • November 2019
  • August 2019
  • July 2019
  • June 2019
  • May 2019
  • March 2019
  • February 2019
  • January 2019
  • October 2018
  • September 2018
  • August 2018
  • June 2018
  • May 2018
PJM Law

Contact Us

Peterson, Johnson & Murray — Chicago LLC

Address:
200 West Adams St. STE 2125
Chicago, IL 60606

Telephone: 312-782-7150
Fax: 312-896-9318

Attorneys

  • Paul A. O’Grady
  • Dominick L. Lanzito
  • Kevin M. Casey
  • Ajay Shah
  • Deanna Rosenbaum Hall
  • Kevin Kearney
  • Thomas Nelligan
  • Jennifer Turiello
  • Joselyn R. Mathews
  • Patrick G. Connelly
  • Shantel I. Perez
  • Thomas J. Condon, Jr.
Copyright 2018-2021 Peterson, Johnson & Murray — Chicago LLC | Disclaimer